Regulatory frameworkLoi 25 + sectoral duties
The private medical clinic — GMF, specialized clinic, multi-specialty clinic — operates under the densest regulatory stack of the six covered sectors: Bill 25 as a private entity, LSSSS (CQLR, c. S-4.2) for medical secrecy, Act P-9.0001 for health-information sharing, and the Code of professional conduct of physicians.
- Bill 25
- applicable as to any private organization; collection limited to the clinical mandate.
- Act respecting health services and social services (CQLR, c. S-4.2), art. 19-19.2
- absolute medical secrecy over any information obtained in the practice of the profession. Disclosure to an unauthorized third party, even incidentally, is a breach.
- Act respecting the sharing of certain health information (CQLR, c. P-9.0001)
- frames the conditions of sharing among establishments and with providers; a U.S. cloud provider hosting or processing health information falls under the Act.
- Code of professional conduct of physicians (CQLR, c. M-9, r. 17), art. 20-23
- medical professional secrecy; duty of prudence in the use of technology tools.
- Act respecting access to documents held by public bodies and the protection of personal information (CQLR, c. A-2.1)
- applicable to public establishments (CIUSSS, CHU), not to private clinics, but the comparable is instructive for assessing the diligence expected by the CAI and by professional inspection.
- Collège des médecins du Québec — "Position on AI tools in clinical practice"
- explicitly recommends, for transcription tools, on-premises execution or cloud infrastructure under Canadian jurisdiction with contract; specific mention of risks tied to U.S. Whisper-as-a-service.
The practical consequence is known to every clinic that has deployed a transcription tool since 2022: Wispr Flow, Dragon Medical Cloud, and U.S.-hosted Whisper-as-a-service integrations transmit raw audio or transcripts to U.S. servers. Each of these transfers is, on its own, a potential breach of LSSSS art. 19, of Act P-9.0001, and of Bill 25 art. 17.